A church in Italy has found itself at the center of a heated controversy following the display of a “blasphemous” nativity scene. The Church of Saints Peter and Paul, located in Capocastello di Mercogliano, faced backlash for its decision to feature a same-sex couple in place of Joseph, alongside the figures of the Virgin Mary and the baby Jesus. This unconventional portrayal aimed to promote inclusivity and reflect the evolving nature of modern families.

The priest responsible for the nativity scene, Father Vitaliano Della Sala, defended his decision, stating that he intended to depict the changing dynamics of families in today’s society. Della Sala expressed the importance of recognizing diverse family structures, including those of separated and divorced individuals, gay couples, single parents, and young mothers. By showcasing a same-sex couple in the nativity scene, he aimed to convey a message of inclusivity and acceptance.

The same-sex nativity scene, with one of the Mary figures draped in rainbow colors, quickly drew criticism from various quarters. Pro-Vita & Famiglia, a pro-life group, initiated an online petition calling for the removal of the nativity scene, labeling it as “blasphemous and provocative.” The petition argued that the scene distorted the traditional meaning of the Nativity and the Holy Family by omitting Saint Joseph and promoting a practice as illegal as the buying and selling of gametes.

Priest in Italy creates a same-sex nativity scene. Replaces St. Joseph with another woman, who is shrouded in LGBT colours.

Over to you Holy Father. pic.twitter.com/1LuXnhxET6

— Timeless Faith ✠ (@timelessfaithh) December 24, 2023

At the time of this publication, the petition has garnered significant support, with nearly reaching its goal of 25,000 signatures. Senator Maurizio Gasparri, a member of the co-ruling Forza Italia party, voiced his opposition to the nativity scene, stating that it “offends all those who always had respect and devotion for the Holy Family.” The controversy surrounding the same-sex nativity scene has ignited a fierce debate about the intersection of religion, tradition, and inclusivity.

Notably, Father Della Sala pointed to the recent move by Pope Francis, which allowed priests to bless same-sex couples. This papal directive, regarded by many as a significant step toward inclusivity within the Catholic Church, has sparked both praise and criticism. Supporters argue that it aligns with the Pope’s emphasis on compassion and mercy, while detractors view it as a departure from traditional teachings. The inclusion of a same-sex couple in the nativity scene can be seen as an echo of Pope Francis’ message of acceptance.

The LGBT nativity scene has evoked strong reactions from individuals and organizations across the globe. While some applaud the attempt to promote inclusivity, others argue that it undermines the sanctity of the Nativity and disregards the traditional representation of the Holy Family. Critics perceive the scene as a deliberate affront to religious beliefs and an inappropriate politicization of a sacred tradition.

Supporters of the same-sex nativity scene contend that it represents an important acknowledgment of the diversity within society. They argue that the Church should strive to be inclusive and accepting of all individuals, regardless of their sexual orientation or family structure. The portrayal of a same-sex couple in the nativity scene serves as a symbolic gesture of support for LGBTQ+ individuals and their families.

Artistic interpretations of religious stories have always generated debates and controversies. The nativity scene at the Church of Saints Peter and Paul is no exception. While some argue that artistic liberties should be allowed to express evolving societal norms, others believe that religious symbols and traditions should be preserved in their traditional forms. The clash between artistic expression and religious reverence continues to challenge the boundaries of interpretation and acceptance.

The controversy surrounding the same-sex nativity scene raises fundamental questions about the role of the Church in a rapidly changing world. As societal norms evolve, the Church faces the challenge of remaining relevant while upholding its core values. The inclusion of diverse family structures in the nativity scene can be seen as an attempt to bridge the gap between tradition and modernity, though it has clearly sparked a contentious debate within the Catholic community.